Week 12
2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025
All | American Southwest Conference | Centennial Conference | College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin | Division III Independents | East Coast Football Conference | Empire Eight | Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | Iowa Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Liberty League | Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association | Middle Atlantic Conference | Midwest Conference | Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | New England Football Conference | New England Small College Athletic Conference | New Jersey Athletic Conference | North Coast Athletic Conference | Northern Athletics Conference | Northwest Conference | Ohio Athletic Conference | Old Dominion Athletic Conference | Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Southern Collegiate Athletic Conference | The Presidents' Athletic Conference | University Athletic Association | Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | USA South Conference | Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference
| Place | Team | Rating | Strength of Schedule | +/- | 
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Mount Union (11 - 0) Schedule: -3.254 (8) | 0.707 0.707  | |||
| 2. Heidelberg (9 - 2) Schedule: -3.263 (9) | -0.909 -0.909  | |||
| 3. Otterbein (8 - 2) Schedule: -3.133 (5) | -1.458 -1.458  | |||
| 4. Baldwin-Wallace (7 - 3) Schedule: -3.27 (10) | -2.149 -2.149  | |||
| 5. John Carroll (6 - 4) Schedule: -3.174 (7) | -2.319 -2.319  | |||
| 6. Ohio Northern (4 - 6) Schedule: -3.159 (6) | -3.319 -3.319  | |||
| 7. Muskingum (3 - 7) Schedule: -2.873 (4) | -3.61 -3.61  | |||
| 8. Capital (2 - 8) Schedule: -2.654 (1) | -4.96 -4.96  | |||
| 9. Marietta (0 - 10) Schedule: -2.766 (2) | -5.838 -5.838  | |||
| 10. Wilmington (1 - 9) Schedule: -2.858 (3) | -6.236 -6.236  |